Opinion
Mental Health Crisis In Nigeria: Stereotypes And Neglect
Published
11 months agoon
By Toyin Falola
Driving between Ibadan and Lagos, you will find many men and women roaming the streets, some scavenging for food on refuse dumps. If they wander to markets, they drive them away with sticks, sometimes stoning them. I saw them under bridges in Abeokuta. They are all over the motor parks. A decent society does not treat any of its segments in a manner like this. Too depressing. Turning points do occur in life, and a normal person today can become depressed.
The mindset produces stereotypes that eventually lead to maltreatment, as in the case of stoning to chase away. One example: A Yoruba adage would state, “Were du’n wo loja sugbon kose bi lomo,” meaning it could be fun watching an episode of a mentally sick person, but it is despicable to have one as a child. Madness becomes a drama to entertain the sane!
Among the pool of devastating problems evident in Nigerian society, mental health has become one of the most neglected. The number of the mentally ill—a pool of conditions—is on the rise. The scene of a “mad man or woman” walking freely in society has become common and colloquial that it has been made fun of. Seeing a woman or man walk beside the roadside or dance through the market with some assumed euphoria of communing with spirits seems to be entertaining to the on-lookers. Such a person could be and stay in that area for years, constantly displaying without family, friends, or the government coming to their aid. So, the constant sights and lack of attention given to these people made their sickness a normal phenomenon everyone is probably pleased to see but detest to have as a relative.
While Nigerians understand mental health challenges, both as a sickness and some free public entertainment, the sickness attains deeper constructions. Spiritual attributions to acts of lunacy or episodes have been a disparaging phenomenon, even across Africa. Body parts of a mentally deranged, hair, clothes, and private parts have been seen as viable spiritual instruments for rituals. It goes on to ritual sex and sex predation that have endangered female persons suffering from mental challenges. They have become spiritual conduits that interact with other spiritual plains. They are seen as anjonu, spiritual beings, talking and interacting with other anjonu that cannot be seen. So, they become receptors of sacrificial and spiritual materials. In this light, the number of ritual killings of those suffering from mental challenges has proliferated. Thousands are being killed and mutilated every year across the continent without drawing the necessary attention.
While we ignore the veracity and the seriousness of the issue, Nigerian society tends not to consider the fact that mental illness transcends the highly degenerated cases that are displayed across the road but also some instances that might have been the root causes of many societal issues. Anxiety disorder, depression, PTSD, dissociation and dissociative disorder, OCD, eating disorder, and many others are some of the silent mental conditions to which attention is not given. Many Nigerians are facing depression and stress and lash out at society with overbearing and dangerous consequences without much attention being given to them. The World Health Organization posited that about 20% of Nigerians suffer from one form of mental illness or the other, and some other statistics put it at 25 to 30%. Such is a high number of affected individuals and the lack of attention that the sickness suffers from.
The above posits that about 3 out of every Nigerian suffers from one form of mental challenge or the other, and looking at the possibility of a high rate of undetected challenges among people, the number may be more. It means there is a high chance that in a household of 10 people, there would be a probability of 2 persons with the problem, and in a household of 5, there is a probability of 1 person facing mental challenges. Many of them are kept from public notice or wrongly discreetly diagnosed to be spiritually attacked. These issues become uncontrolled, and at an instance of escape, they become public nuisance and government affairs that the government never attended to.
While these mental health challenges are still stuffed down the throats of society, it seems that you and I have not learned to be conscious of the various means of manifestation. Mental health care still ignorantly seems to be some abstract and lofty affair that money and time are being wasted upon. The concepts of mental health and sanity do not strike individuals as health issues worthy enough to attract attention. The era of social media platforms and daily “cruises” has gradually been ripping society of any modicum of regard, reasonableness, and conscience that one would just make statements that would negatively and mentally change lives forever. The world has seen different celebrities lose their balance and careers crumbling because of comments that toy with the mental sanity of individuals. Parents, teachers, religious leaders, and other individuals make demeaning and dehumanizing statements that will cause a dent in the personality of an individual forever. But because the damage is not a physical wound that could be given first aid attention, they are left unattended, and the slightest complaints are dismissed as mere exaggerations.
From the above, it is obvious that those roaming the streets and roads are not just the “mad people,” but some of the persons who dress in suits and with beautiful appearance may as well be challenged as others but could have been able to put theirs under control. Unfortunately, the future of mental health in Nigeria is bleak. The fact that the figure of the sick roaming unattended to around the streets is increasing is evidence that the few that could be managed may be hopeless shortly. Suicide cases and other unconventional social reactions have been at an alarming rate recently.
The crux of the problem, this time, is not even the government, although they take a significant share of the blame; it bounces back to the people who either lack knowledge, are ignorant or decisively choose not to be conscious of the social consequences of their actions. The maltreatment of children by family and relatives in the misconstrued attempts to discipline the child; the violence that they are made to see while growing up; graphic movies and movies that require parental guidance but are shown to the children notwithstanding; untreated and un-debriefed traumas, constant psychological challenges; hypnotizations of people based on their wants and religions; failures and inability to handle consequence; and other scientific explanation for mental disorder are taken so lightly by individuals. People have failed to realize that mental health is not just a personal issue but that we owe society and every individual not to do things that may put them in danger.
Society, not recognizing the extent of these challenges, has made mental health cases increase drastically in Nigeria. People are often ignorant of the medical angle and explanation of mental health problems. They seek unproven alternatives to the issues. Sometimes, the decisions are based on an attempt to avoid stigmatization of the sick. This rationale is quite reasonable, looking at the fact that the social positioning of the Nigerian society refuses to be conscious of the phenomenon. The stigma extends to the family members as well as becomes a point of reference in the future. This explains why the words “Aro” or “Yaba Left” are colloquially used to insult people. “Aro” is the location of the Federal Neuro-Psychiatric Hospital, Aro, Abeokuta, and “Yaba Left” colloquially describes the Federal Neuro-Psychiatric Hospital, Yaba. Once you are metaphorically insulted to be from there or escaped from there, it means you are described to be deeply mad or mentally derailed. Hence, people avoid seeing their wards there.
Where one could muster the courage to brave the social stigmatization, the problem remains the expensive mental health care. With a poverty rate of 4 in 10 people being extremely poor in Nigeria, only very few people can afford mental health care services and treatments; hence, the alternatives are inefficient treatments that further degenerate the sickness. In some cases, the sessions and therapy could cost about 30,000 to 50,000 naira per session, and one may not be able to anticipate the number of sessions needed. The other drugs, treatments, and surgeries are also quite out of reach of the average Nigerian.
In another vein, the government has refused to adequately fund the mental healthcare sector of the Nigerian healthcare services. An estimate by the World Health Organization posits the Nigerian government does not give more than 3 per cent of the general budget on health to mental health care. Hence, the facilities and treatments are rare and available to only about 10 per cent of the total number of affected individuals. Doctors and nurses taking care of mental illness are badly remunerated.
There are not enough psychiatric or mental health experts in Nigeria. The country has only eight Federal psychiatric hospitals, eight professional schools for psychiatric nursing, and just twelve medical schools that are competent in mental health care. More so, many of the facilities, both public, private, and state, are largely seen in the southern part of the country and centred in the urban centres.
As a result of these shortcomings, there are just 0.4 beds available for every 100,000 people in Nigeria. There are also just 0.09 professional psychiatrists, 0.02 psychologists, and 4 psychiatric nurses available to 100,000 persons in the country. There is also a lack of trained mental health nurses and social workers, which makes it difficult to provide comprehensive care.
A viral video of a nurse chasing down a mentally ill patient who had escaped a mental institution is an index to the inadequacy of medical hands because how was such a patient able to escape a facility? This caricature speaks to the soul of mental health practices in Nigeria; as such, a determined nurse came off as a mental person in the chase of her patient. The few mental health professionals that do exist in Nigeria often face burnout due to the high demand for their services and the limited resources available to them. So, after overcoming the shame and stigma and being able to afford some treatments, good medical attentions are not guaranteed because of the lack of attention given to the sector by the government.
The government has largely left the responsibility of combatting mental health in Nigeria to the hands of private individuals and Non-Governmental Organizations, which are not enough to cater to the mental health needs of the nation. One cannot overstretch the need for the government to give adequate attention to these sectors to appreciate and complement the efforts of the private and NGOs that have made attempts in the past.
It is also apparent that there is a need for constant reorientation of the Nigerian physical and virtual spaces if the proliferation of mental health challenges must stop. Society must see every individual as much human as they are and also recognize that everyone is an agent of mental health awareness. Injuries caused to the physical bodies are seen and mostly appreciated, but the concealment of this type of sickness does not make it less important. Research has shown that mental health challenges could amount to an increase in social vices in society. Hence, to protect oneself or society, one must be conscious of the mental health of oneself and others.
You may like
-
Leadership Ethics Template For Reinventing Akinyele Era Of Civil Service In Nigeria
-
Olaopa Emerges AAPSCOMS’ Vice President As Nigeria Hosts Body In 2026
-
Can Democracy Work In Nigeria?
-
Nigeria: As A New Railway Dawn Beckons
-
Toyin Falola’s Suggestion Of The New Academic Field Of African Ancestral Studies
-
Mental Health, Accusations Of Witchcraft And Demonic Possession In Nigeria
By Leo Igwe
The Advocacy for Alleged Witches (AfAW) is concerned over the reported arrest of two men accused of being ‘witchdoctors’ in Zambia. The arrest underscores the potency of witchcraft fears and the connection between occult anxieties and the country’s politics. These individuals were accused of trying to bewitch the Zambian president, Hakainde Hichilema. The police claimed that they had charms. They planned to use the charms to harm the president. The report says the two persons have been charged under Zambia’s Witchcraft Act. The Act criminalizes “possession of charms”, “professing knowledge of witchcraft”, and “cruelty to wild animals”. The police found the two with assorted charms, including a live chameleon.
This development is utterly embarrassing and shows that the Zambian government is slowly losing its focus and bearing.The country has many socio-economic challenges. Suspicion of bewitchment or possession of charms should be the least of its worries at this time. There should be no place for witchcraft and possession of charms in modern politics because there is no evidence for these beliefs and practices. Zambian authorities should not weaponize the Witchcraft Act or use it to justify this incident. Zambian law does not recognize witchcraft. Zambia’s Witchcraft Act criminalizes naming or imputing witchcraft. It prohibits accusing or threatening to accuse any person of being a witch or a wizard. In this case, it is the police who are breaking the law.
Otherwise, how did they know the two individuals were ‘witchdoctors’? Did these persons identify as witch doctors? If not, the police are liable because they named and imputed witchcraft and have to prove that these individuals have witch-doctoring powers. The police claimed to have charged these individuals for possessing “assorted charms”, including a chameleon. Really?
The police in Zambia have questions to answer: What are charms? How did they know that what was in their possession were charms, not pets? Is a chameleon a form of charm? What makes possession of a chameleon possession of a charm? When and how does a chameleon become a charm? The police need to answer these questions and more before one takes them seriously.
Again, did the individuals describe what was in possession as ‘charms’? If they did, does confessing or designating something as a charm make it a charm? And if they did not, the police are liable because they need to prove how those possessions translated into charms.
In addition, the police claimed that the duo wanted to bewitch the president. What does that mean? How did they know? Are the police not contravening a provision under the Witchcraft Act by professing knowledge of witchcraft? Can one harm another person using a chameleon? They claimed that the two persons wanted to use the charms in their possession, including the chameleon to harm the president. How did they know that? What is the evidence for that?
The Advocacy for Alleged Witches calls for an end to this state-sponsored witch hunt. There is no evidence of harm through witchcraft or charms. The Zambian government should desist from witchcraft- related infractions and violations including arbitrary arrest, and detention of innocent citizens. These allegations are baseless and absurd. The arrest was politically motivated. This development demonstrates that Zambian authorities are out of sync with their duty and obligation to uphold the rule of law and protect accused persons.
Zambian authorities need to act in compliance with the 2021 UN resolution, which urged states to take measures to combat abuses linked to witchcraft beliefs and ritual attacks. End witchcraft allegations in Zambia. End witch hunts in Africa now!
Dr Igwe directs the Advocacy for Alleged Witches.
By Tony Afejuku
The other burning issue, apart from Farotimi and Babalola’s, which I wish to take a look at – and which I am taking a look at now – relates to what is happening in our capital territory. What is this burning issue – which our human rightists and civil society organisations and personages are surprisingly and un-satisfactorily not inclined to focus attention on and examine as they should? I may be wrong, but it surely seems to me that this issue, this burning issue, which is of more importance than Farotimi and Babalola’s – which has been given undue adulation – is deliberately being neglected and depreciated by proclaimers and heroes and heroines of human rights, justice, equity and equality of rights in your country my country our country. Why, why, why and why, why, why? Anyone who has any iota of patriotic sensibility, feeling and judgment well watered and buttressed by a very great influence upon his or her critical judgment will keep on asking the question I am asking.
Mr. Nyesom Wike, as almost everybody who can read and write a little knows, is the current minister of your, my and our Federal Capital Territory. His post or office is akin to that of a governor of a state. As the immediate past governor of Rivers State who was drafted, after his two terms there expired, to continue in the FCT as its new minister-governor or governor-minister under the auspices of a party he is not a true member of, Mr. Wike cannot but be seen as a lucky man. He is in every possible and impossible way. Minister-Governor Wike is a lucky man and a very fortunate one indeed. No former governor of Rivers State (or of any Nigerian state), as far as I know, has achieved what the famed political rouser of rabbles has achieved in one short gubernatorial life-time, and at a relatively young and fertile age. His dual achievement with and in two different political parties at this delicate point of Nigerian politics indicates to our politicians and us all that there is always time for a reminder that there are ready-made high rewards for arch-angels of betrayals. And Mr. Wike may go down in Rivers and Nigerian history as both an arch-angel and an emperor of betrayal of us all if we attempt to indicate what I have defined here as his dual achievement.
We can roughly divide, briefly, Wike’s political development into two periods. During the first, excluding his lower political positions before he became the governor of Rivers State, he quickly adapted his style to that of an emperor who became a rabble-rouser of rabble-rousers whose gubernatorial efficiency moved from stiffness to stiffness. He did not at any time feel that he needed suppleness to govern Rivers State. “Let the heavens fall if they must fall!” We are not there yet in this attempted analysis of the stiff-hearted and stiff-minded one. True? But he is already demonstrating this characteristic in Abuja. False? Judge and give the answer yourself.
Even after he left Rivers State a short while ago as governor, he is still trying to control happenings there to the political discomfiture of his hand-picked successor, his erstwhile “boy” and “son” – with whom he has fallen out. As the minister-governor or governor-minister of the FCT, Wike is occupied with the other taste of the emperor-juggernaut formulator – doing the work of two key political masters in one room and desk of political jugglery. Since his appearance in the FCT, minister-governor or governor-minister Wike has allegedly attempted to recover or transform for Abuja what is not traditionally or socially Abuja’s, for example, the city’s social idiom and landscape and terrain as well as its environs. In doing this he sometimes over-steps his bounds and mark of human/inhuman decency/indecency and psychological understanding of human nature, if you follow well what I am saying; he has so far become at best not really better than a typical pedestrian Nigerian lawyer and officer of political power: in his explorations so far in the Federal Capital Territory we have come to the realization, as T. S. Eliot would say, that “it is so often true that only by going too far can we find out how far we can go.” But one has to be a very negatively obstinate and self-serving emperor and a thorough-bred arch-angel of betrayal of the people and masses to justify such perilous and perfidious expeditions and adventures.
Last week, I saw on Arise Television “The Morning Show” Chief Rita Lori-Ogbebor, the dutiful widow of the late Nigerian supreme patriot and soldier, Colonel Ogbebor (of Benin stock) battling, so to say, to wrest the legacy of her late husband from the tight grip of the adventurous FCT minister-governor who has registered his name and signature in the hearts and consciousness of the people as the depriver of their possessions. The three anchors of “The Morning Show” were in their respective ways splendid in their structures of remarks and questions to Chief (Mrs.) Rita Lori-Ogbebor whom I have had occasions in times past to call patriotically Rita A-K 47 on account of her natural right to fire her beautiful tongue at any person, usually an enemy, of just actions. When she made the case she made to protect the estate of Paulosa Nigeria Limited, her late husband’s aforesaid legacy in the FCT, she was in her natural territory, habitat and element where even at age eighty-four, she never ever loses her stability – although she unusually restrained herself in the Arise Television appearance. Dr. Reuben Abati, Rufai Oseni, and Ayo Mairo-Ese clearly explored seriously but delightfully the mind of the mother-hen of Warri – my other coinage and appellation I gave her in my poetry. Her “The Morning Show” appearance enabled me to see the poignant cry de profundis of the FCT inhabitants whose property and residences in different guises have been demolished. She did not say anything that was out of joint. She spoke and came out as a mother, protector and symbol of the people who have suffered – and are suffering – from the state of affliction and anguish Wike’s demolitions have placed – and are placing – the people.
Ojy Okpe in her delicious and delectable “What is Trending” slot on the same show, showed without exaggeration but with further elaboration what people in and outside Abuja/FCT think of the mighty Wike’s demolitions, a burning issue that the Senate has asked “Let Heaven Fall” minister-governor Wike to halt as the committee the Senate set up on the issue starts its work. Of course, we cannot but assume that Chief Rita Lori-Ogbebor, Mrs. Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan as well as Mrs. Ireti Kingigbe, the senator representing the FCT in the Senate and other patriotic senators diligently did what they did on the floor of the Senate when the burning issue was tabled for debate with the gracious understanding and authorization of the Senate President.
I need to state further that the “The Morning Show” anchors did well and extremely so by giving the minister-governor the opportunity to air his anti-Paulosa story. His senior special assistant on public communication and social media, Mr. Olalere Olayinka, stood in for him. After he gave the reasons for the clamp-down, his responses to the questions the anchors put to him followed the usual pattern of denials by artificial men in power – denials that they always use to intimidate and betray the people. In fact, Mr. Olayinka’s ploy to ride easily over our dear Rufai Oseni, a wholesome representative of the deprived, that the chap (or is it guy?) and his boss always employ their colloquial speeches and remarks to dishonor, failed. Yes, the ploy failed woefully. In stanza after stanza of the exchanges between Mr. Olayinka and the Arise anchors, he deteriorated – and his deterioration was hall-marked when he unwittingly revealed that the Paulosa land had been acquired by his minister-governor’s close cohort, an act that was nothing short of gross abuse of power and authority.
Because the Senate is already using its authority, power and privilege to resolve the burning issue, hopefully, in a way that the late Colonel Ogbebor’s legacy and family will not be subjected to any kind of degradation, I will utter no more words for now. I trust, however, that the liberties the Senate is taking – or has taken – are for the sake of order to favour the down-trodden.
As for the minister-governor, the PDP emperor at large, here is an immortal quote from Marcus Aurelius, the magnificent and authentic Roman Emperor and philosopher (A.D. 121-180): “If it is not right, do not do it; if it is not true, do not say it.” You lose nothing by giving us a slice of your humanity by your right acts and correct words. Everything changes and passes. Be humane as a human being.
Afejuku can be reached via 08055213059.
By Leo Igwe
Recently, I facilitated a critical thinking workshop at the Bay Wreath Schools in Lagos. The theme was critical thinking and teacher development. As the theme stated, the workshop was on teaching, about teaching, and for teachers. It highlighted the pedagogical value of critical and reflective inquiry. The workshop exposed teachers to critical mental habits and skills. It emphasized how critical thinking would enhance expertise in the learning and delivery of subjects in classrooms.
I used the opportunity to discuss questionstorm as a method of teaching and learning. Questionstorm is a way that I operationalized critical thinking for primary and elementary schools. Questionstorm is the ability to interrogate all objects and materials. It is a habit of questioning ideas and experiences in all areas of human endeavor. Simply put, questionstorm is a question-driven inquiry. Children are naturally curious. They thirst for knowledge and understanding. Unfortunately, the school system kills children’s curiosity and dampens their interrogative appetite. The school system places much emphasis on rote learning and memorization. It makes the generation of answers not questions or problems the test of knowledge, and the determinant of intelligence. Teaching is largely a drudgery, a monotonous exercise, and a process of depositing knowledge on passive recipients, the students. Teaching entails dumping information on learners whose duty is to cram and reproduce during tests or examinations.
This teaching praxis has been criticized and blamed for the poor performance of students post-school (college and university) and their inability to think independently, creatively, and innovatively. Other teaching methods have tried to address these gaps and limitations. There have been suggestions to make teaching and instruction more active, and more student/learner/child-centered. One such method is the Montessori method. The Montessori method discourages grades and tests as ways of measuring achievement or determining intelligence and excellence. It emphasizes hands-on learning and the development of real-world skills. While the Montessori method stresses the practical approach to learning it says very little about the authoritarian teacher-to-student approach that is the mainstay of teaching and learning in classrooms. Teaching follows a pattern that leaves students and learners in the margins and unable to question and contribute to the learning process. Teachers present what is to be learned such as a text, and then generate questions that students respond or address to demonstrate knowledge of what has been taught. The student’s or learner’s main job is to answer questions, to look for or find answers or solutions. The teacher’s work is to get students to look for, and provide answers, and reproduce what they have been taught or told. But students are answer-depots. Students are not memory banks or reserves. They are active minds and thinking agents.
With questionstorm as a teaching method, the mode of instruction would change. Teaching becomes a cooperative endeavor that actively involves teachers and students. What is taught in the classroom is a collaborative note, not the teacher’s note, not a handout to students. Teachers present or generate texts or objects for learning, in response to intense questioning of the object or material by students, teachers provide information as required for that subject, topic, level, and time frame. No two instances of teaching – of the same topic or subject- are or should be the same because the input of students and teachers is not predetermined.
This is because of an overlooked principle in teaching and learning, that I call the “uncertainty principle”.
The uncertainty principle underlies questionstorm because knowledge is not fixed. Learning is a fluid process. All that is to be learned is uncertain, it is unknown and never determined. No teacher can say beforehand what is to be taught or learned because no one knows exactly the questions and answers or replies that would arise when a topic is presented or taught in a particular class. A topic or learning material elicits unique responses and exchanges that both teachers and students cannot exactly know or predict a priori, before the fact.
Teaching is a shared task and responsibility. Class notes are fluid materials. They are not texts cast on educational stones and delivered by teachers to students to copy, cut, and paste as is often the case. Class notes are not written or produced by teachers for students but by teachers with students. Teachers’ notes are incomplete and insufficient. They account only for a part, not a whole of the learning process and material. Students’ input completes and complements the teaching material and learning process. Thus every class note is unique because it is a product of a specific collaborative endeavor, a product of particular teaching and learning agents and circumstances that cannot be repeated or replicated.
Thus, as a teaching method, questionstorm is set to facilitate teacher development and improve the quality of instruction in schools. Questionstorm will help realize a paradigm shift in education and learning. I hope educators, teachers, and school managers will embrace this method of teaching and learning.
Dr Igwe directs the Critical Thinking Social Empowerment Foundation.
Inline image
NEW TIMES CULTURE
Fear Of Witchcraft And Politics In Zambia
Black Saturday As 10 Confirmed Dead, Others Injured In Abuja Church Stampede
Tinubu Congratulates Civil Service Commission Chair Olaopa As He Turns 65
Top Stories
-
Latest News14 hours ago
Black Saturday As 10 Confirmed Dead, Others Injured In Abuja Church Stampede
-
Opinion2 days ago
Burning Issues: (FCT Minister And Paulosa) (2)
-
Metro3 days ago
AfAW Decries Court Acquittal Of Suspected Murderer Of Alleged Witch In Enugu
-
Latest News4 days ago
Why We Set Up Kojola Dry Port – Abiodun
-
Opinion3 days ago
Questionstorm As A Method Of Teaching