Connect with us

For The Record

Witch Persecution And Penis Disappearance: Why We Need Critical Thinking Corners In Nigeria

Published

on

Witch Burning, Impunity And Abuses Linked to Witchcraft Beliefs In Benue State
Dr. Leo Igwe
By Leo Igwe
I bring you all greetings and salutations from the Humanist Association of Nigeria and from all who value critical thinking and reasoned inquiry across the world. We commend you all for this initiative, and for staging the first edition of the hangout of the Critical Thinkers Corner in Ebonyi State. Bravo! We believe this hangout is the first of many more events to come. It is the beginning of critical things and more profound initiatives to promote a more rational and scientific approach to life in Ebonyi state. As you may be aware, critical thinking is one thing that is lacking so much in our society. Critical thinking is something that we need in a large dosage and proportion. We need to vigorously promote the ability to analyze, evaluate, and interrogate issues, beliefs, and claims.
To this end, I founded an organization, the Critical Thinking Social Empowerment Foundation, that fosters critical thinking skills in schools, and the society at large. We cannot overemphasize the fact that there is power in thinking critically; that people can be empowered, emancipated and liberated through the application of these mental habits. At the Humanist Association, we place a great premium on critical thinking abilities. Because due to the lack of critical thinking, humanity suffers. To phrase it differently, due to the lack of critical thinking corners, people perish. Our society is smoldering away. Many people cannot breathe. Families and communities are suffocating to death. People suffer terrible abuses. People are murdered with impunity. People are dying needlessly. As a matter of urgency, the Nigerian society needs critical thinking corners.
And this event is happening at a crucial time in the history of the country, at a time when the people of Ebonyi, Nigeria, and Africa are grappling with superstition and religion-based abuses in many ways, and on different fronts.
It may interest you to know that I came in for this event from Calabar, where an exhibition is ongoing at the state museum. This exhibition is the first of its kind. A Nigerian artist, Etinosa Yvonne, staged the event in partnership with the National Geographic Society and the Basic Counsel Rights Initiative in Calabar. The exhibition titled, It’s All in the Head, is an educative and enlightening program. The exhibition uses photos, images, and illustrations to show the devastating impact of witchcraft accusations and witch persecutions. We had a case here in Ebonyi state where an accused person was tortured and then thrown into a river. Nobody has seen the corpse to date. Efforts to bring the suspects to justice have been unsuccessful. Many people have died or disappeared that way without a trace. Peddlers and entertainers of witchcraft imaginaries silently eliminate many persons, parents, children and other family and community members. Superstitions have made us lose our humanity, our sense of compassion for one another. And here at the Critical Thinking Corner we should say it loud and clear: Enough is enough. Based on what transpires in one’s head, people are brutally attacked, tortured, and murdered with impunity. People are living with traumas for the rest of their lives. As the exhibition rightly said, it is all in the head. It is all in our heads. Yes. witchcraft is all in the heads of the believers, the heads of accusers, hunters, and persecutors. And the time has come to begin the surgical process to expel and disable this social, cultural and mental virus.
As you may have heard, another superstitious ill wind is blowing across the country as we gather here.  Another imaginary bug is eating up the heads, minds, and conscience of Nigerians with devastating impact on the suspects. That is the so-called magical disappearance or thieving of penises. Do penises magically disappear? The answer is No. There is no evidence that people’s private parts  disappear following a touch or a handshake. But to many Nigerians the answer is: Yes. Like all magical or superstitious beliefs, the idea of the magical disappearance of the penis is absurd. The notion of the magical theft of a private part is a figment of the mind, a mind petrified by fear, and anxiety, ignorance and superstition. It is a supposition in the ‘head’ with a external impact that is brutal. This week, a lecturer was accused and mobbed in Makurdi, Benue state. He sustained serious injuries. But you know what? He was lucky. He survived. The police intervened and rescued him. Many people accused of this imaginary offense have been beaten to death in some parts of the country. In Adamawa, the police stopped students from lynching some suspects. So our educators and educational institutions are not spared. Even in schools, colleges, and universities, people can be accused, attacked, and lynched for the magical disappearance of the penis in 21st-century Nigeria. What a shame!
So, we need to take what goes on in our ‘heads’ seriously. We need to critically examine what goes on in the minds of people around us. We need to interrogate narratives that are used to sanction and sanctify cruelty and savage acts in the communities. That is why, from time to time, we need to break, hang out, pause, reflect, and congregate at critical thinking corners. We need to create forums where we examine, ponder, and interrogate ideas, claims, and beliefs that often inform our actions and behaviors. Humanity cannot progress without a vibrant culture of skeptical rationality. Skepticism unlocks human possibilities, and guarantees hope for the future. Humanity’s best and brightest cannot manifest if we cannot interrogate ideas and beliefs.
So, skepticism is the handmaid of humanism. The skeptical outlook provides a springboard for the flourishing of the humanist cosmology. Skepticism is the driver and propeller of humanist values, and undergirds a progressive ethical living. As humanists, we need to work and campaign for a more critical thinking society. We need to invest in the promotion and application of critical thinking skills in all areas of human endeavor. At the Humanist Association, we encourage the creation of critical thinking spaces to help beat back the tide of dogma, blind faith, and superstition-based abuses. In the months ahead, the Humanist Association of Nigeria will follow, with keen interest, the activities of the Critical Thinkers Corner in Ebonyi state. The association will endeavor to provide you with all that you need to grow and develop this resource. Be assured of my personal support and that of other humanists and critical thinkers in Nigeria and beyond.
We hope you have a socially nourishing, thought provoking and intellectually stimulating fellowship.
. Dr Igwe is a board member of the Humanist Association of Nigeria.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

For The Record

The Palamadi Fall

Published

on

Dele Jegede In Conversation With Prince Yemisi Shyllon
Prof. Toyin Falola

By Toyin Falola

The ancient Greek stones, time’s sentinels, align,
Their whispers weave with the winds’ resigned sighs.
A thousand steps, hewn out of will and design,
Call out the brave to the skies of the Venetians.

Every rise makes my heart a fast-beating drum,
The Argolic Gulf expands as a timeless sea.
Strangers go before, their strength steadfast,
While my family mounts upwards in boldness.

But at the topmost stair, fate played its freak,
A slip, a fall, the edge of the world thrown.
My head struck stone; my body, at rest—
The fortress walls my weakness thrown.

The echoes of fear rose from behind,
Three voices cried, their anguish shared.
Yet life, that dogged thread, still aligned,
And from it, I emerged repaired.

I rose with bruises, humbled, sore
But my spirit, Leonidas, roared to rise.
To stand and climb was my sacred chore,
To touch the heavens, claim the prize.

Finally, the summit wind stroked my face,
The bastions whispered: heroes past.
Kolokotronis, Achilles-their mighty grace,
Speaking to me that strength shall always last.

Then came my family and stood next to me, proud and serene,
Their courage-a mirror to who I could have been.
I gazed at my son and my daughter, their shine,
Their future, a fortress stronger than me.

Going down, the steps became small,
A survived journey-a life regained.
Palamidi heights, its rise, its fall,
Forever etched in memory’s frame.

For information on the Palamidi, see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palamidi

Continue Reading

For The Record

Toyin Falola And The Tree Of Knowledge : Visual Configurations And Projections Of Self Between The Mythic And The Everyday ( 1)

Published

on

Dele Jegede In Conversation With Prince Yemisi Shyllon
Prof. Toyin Falola

By Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju

                                                             Compcros

Comparative Cognitive Processes and Systems

“Exploring Every Corner of the Cosmos in Search of Knowledge”

A collage of Falola book and memorabilia images chosen to emphasize an understanding of some of the most salient qualities projected by  Falola iconography.

The image selection  and organization are inspired by Buddhist mandala technique and possible theoretical interpretations in which diverse images of human forms inspired by the same historical figure are used in evoking abstract concepts in a variety of symbolic visual settings, facilitating contemplative  identification with the values the images crystallize.

            Abstract

This essay examines the immediate and more distant yet strikingly illuminating implications of the use, in his books and memorabilia of him,  of artistic images of polymathic scholar, writer and institutional organizer Toyin Falola, exploring these images within an intercultural context, generating  a global nexus in relation to their  proximate African frameworks.

The essay initiates  what is likely to be a new field of study, Falola iconography, the study of values relating to images of Toyin Falola, part of Falola Studies, the investigation of the life and  work of the scholar, writer and academic entrepreneur.

I have identified the artists responsible for the images when I could get their names from the books.

Creating an Imagistic Universe

Toyin Falola, with the aid of photographers and artists, has been making a point of placing his artistically rendered image on the covers of a significant number of his books, and pictures and art of himself, alone or with others, in the interiors of those books. Others have complemented his efforts by doing the same thing in books about him and memorabilia associated with him.

              A realistic artistic depiction of Toyin Falola

Some of these are realistic images, doing nothing more than projecting an artistic likeness.  Others do more, suggesting symbolic values by depicting Falola in contexts that tell a story which may be interpreted as visual complements to the scholarly explorations in the books.

We see him on the cover of his Daily Life in Colonial Africa, 2024, elegantly dressed in a Yoruba shirt, face shaped by a stylish white beard, seated as a trader in front of  his wares in an African market.

                                               

He is also depicted, in his Milestones in African Literature2024, in art by Getty Ekele and Michael Effionayi, responsible for the various images in that book. He is again sporting that white beard and those Yoruba clothes, seated under a tree, talking with children seated in a circle around him, as the tree’s shade covers speaker and listeners.                 

A large tree grows from his head in another visualization in  Milestones, his face marked by that carefully trimmed white beard, his countenance configured in terms of shapes defined by reflection across decades. Around his brow is a circlet projecting elegance and quiet majesty in the style of the classical beauty of iconic Ife sculptural heads, as a massive tree grows from the top of his head, the branches of the tree named after bodies of knowledge Falola has addressed in his decades long career-the Ifa knowledge system, the African Ajami script, rituals, history, poetry,  prose, drama, nation, the Swahili language.

               

In yet another visualization, in a painting by Moses Ogunleye, from Falola’s In Praise of Greatness: A Poetics of African Adulation, 2019, we see his clearly identifiable face ensconced under a mask within the multifariously coloured robes of an Egungun, a messenger from the world of the finally departed, someone who has returned to Earth from orun, the world of ultimate origins and of final destinations, from where creation began, from where each person issues at the beginning of a lifetime and to which they return at the end of each lifetime, as understood in Yoruba masquerade traditions and their grounding in Yoruba thought.

                                                                   

                                                                                 

In another image the slenderly built Falola, his white bearded face unmistakable, is shown laboriously but successfully holding aloft the structure of Nigeria in the form of a map of the nation, as the title of the book on which this image appears, Understanding Modern Nigeria: Ethnicity, Democracy and Development,  highlights the enormity of the cognitive task the book performs and which the image projects by association, evoking cognitive activity by depicting physical effort.

                         

In still another visualization, in front of the bag given to conference attendees at the conference to mark his sixty-fifth birthday in 2018, Falola’s face is seen  wearing a Yoruba cap, poised in contemplative abstraction, part of a semi-circle of visual icons of African cultural history as that history focuses the continent’s economic, artistic, technological and philosophical development-the inimitable vertical projections of the pyramids, the Sankofa bird of Akan Adinkra symbolism, its backward looking stance evoking learning from the past, the outline of a camel suggesting the trade routes and cultural transmissions enabled by the unique capacities of the camel in movement across the Sahara, an Ife sculptural head completing the lower end of the semi-circle of images, its sense of lofty humanity projected in minimalist yet unmistakably eloquent lines.

Continue Reading

For The Record

River Gods, River Ports, War Canoes And Regattas: Humans And Water Bodies In Historical Time And Space

Published

on

Prof. Yakubu A. Ochefu

By Yakubu A. Ochefu 

Introduction 

Water bodies like rivers, lakes, and oceans, have played indispensable roles in human history, serving as sources of sustenance, trade routes, and symbols of spiritual and cultural identity. This short keynote, explores the intricate relationship between humans and water bodies throughout history, examining the multifaceted influence of water on human societies across various periods and geographical locations. The paper analyses how water has shaped religious beliefs, economic systems, political structures, and cultural practices through an interdisciplinary lens. By investigating historical cases and drawing upon contemporary scholarship, specifically focusing on the River Benue, the paper highlights the enduring significance of water in shaping human civilisation. It underscores the pressing need for sustainable water management in the present and future.

Water as the Lifeblood of Human Society 

In the middle of the fifth century BCE, Empedocles of Acragas formulated a philosophical theory that recognised air, water, earth, and fire as the four elements that bind human civilisation. While the debate on which of the four was paramount, water is often regarded as the “lifeblood” that has shaped human history profoundly, influencing religious practices, economic activities, political dynamics, and cultural expressions. From sacred rivers to water deities, water has been imbued with spiritual significance in countless cultures, shaping religious practices and communities’ worldviews. Culturally, it has profoundly impacted expressions, from rituals and festivals to art and literature. Water is a source of inspiration and symbolises life, death, renewal, and purification. It has also been a critical driver of economic activities, from agriculture and fishing to trade and transportation. The availability and control of water resources have historically determined economic prosperity and power. Access to water has been a source of conflict and cooperation throughout history, influencing the rise and fall of empires and shaping political boundaries.

Historical Perspectives

From ancient civilisations of Mesopotamia, where the Tigris and Euphrates rivers were vital for the development of that civilisation, fueling agriculture, fostering trade and the rise of urbanisation, to ancient Egypt, where the Nile River provided the lifeblood of ancient Egyptian civilisation, supporting agriculture, transportation, and religious practices, water bodies have always been foundational in humanity’s development. The Indus River was the basis of the civilisation that provided sustenance and facilitated the growth of a flourishing urban civilisation. Water is a significant factor in the world’s major Religions. In Hinduism, the Ganges River serves as a purifying force, where rituals like bathing signify spiritual cleansing. For Christians, water serves a role in baptism as a symbol of purification and new beginnings, while in Islam,  it is mentioned in the Quran as a life-giving resource, and it is essential in the context of cleanliness.

Throughout Africa, water is revered as a source of life and fertility, deeply entwined with spiritual beliefs and ritual practices. From the veneration of rain deities and river spirits to the use of water in purification ceremonies and healing rituals, water is a powerful symbol of life, renewal, and spiritual connection. Many rivers and lakes hold religious significance across Africa. The Nile River, for example, is revered in Egyptian mythology as a sacred waterway associated with the god Hapi and representing life, fertility, and rebirth. Similarly, Lake Victoria, the largest lake in Africa, holds spiritual significance for communities in the surrounding regions. In many African cultures, water bodies are believed to be inhabited by ancestral spirits who play a vital role in shaping the lives of the living. These spirits are often invoked in ceremonies and rituals, and their presence is believed to influence the flow of water and the prosperity of communities. In many African cultures, water bodies serve as a source of identity and belonging. Communities living near rivers, lakes, and coastal areas often have strong ties to these water bodies, which are embedded in their histories, traditions, sports, recreation and cultural identities.

From an economic perspective, water has been the backbone of African economies for centuries, sustaining agricultural production and supporting vibrant fishing communities. From the fertile Nile Valley to the vast agrarian landscapes of West Africa, the Tchad and Congo Basin, water access is critical for food security and livelihoods. They have also facilitated trade and transportation across Africa, connecting communities and, fostering economic growth and serving as key arteries for the movement of goods, people, and ideas. In recent times, the harnessing of water power for electricity generation has played a significant role in modernising African economies, providing energy for industrial development and urban growth.

Water power has always been a major factor in politics. Given its role as gateways, the control of water routes has been key to building political power. Major political powers in pre-colonial Africa drew their strength from controlling waterways. The mighty empires of ancient Ghana, Mali, Songhai, and Kanem Borno, had their existence and power to major water bodies.

The penetration of Africa by imperialist forces was also done largely via the waterways. In contemporary times, major infrastructure such as hydroelectric dams have been built on all the major rivers in Africa. Competition for water resources has also been a source of tension and conflict. River basins shared by multiple countries often lead to disputes over water allocation and access, while drought and water scarcity have been known to exacerbate tensions.



The Benue River and its Valley as a Political and Economic Hub



The Benue River and its valley represent one of Africa’s biggest cultural, economic and political corridors. Together with the Nile, Niger, Congo, Zambezi and Limpopo, the Benue has served as a political and economic hub striding two countries and five states and across two geo-political zones. Its nearly 1,483 km of flow is home to some of the major ethnic groups in Central Nigeria, like the Bachama, Jukun, Fulani, Alago, Idoma, Igala, Bassa and Tiv. Major settlements on the banks of the River like Garoua, Yola, Numan, Lau, Ibi, Tunga, Abinsi, Makurdi, Shata, Bagana, Umaisha and Lokoja have at one time served or still serve as administrative and commercial capitals. The major tributaries of the Benue include rivers Taraba, Katsina-ala, Taraba, Donga, Gongola, Faro, Mada, and Mayo-Kebi. The Benue Valley is generally divided into two broad zones. Upper Benue (from Cameroun, through Adamawa to Taraba State. Lower Benue (from Nasarawa, through Benue to Kogi State) The entire stretch is navigable only during the rainy seasons from August to early October. The river is very rich with indigenous varieties of fish such as the famous Lates niloticus (giwan ruwa), West African manatee (Trichechus senegalensis) and Crocdylus Niloticus ( Nile crocodile). Initial Exploration by the NNPC has shown that the Benue through has significant  Oil and Gas resources and   is currently billed as a strategic reserve for the nation. Solid Mineral deposits in the region include Limestone, Galena, Lead, Silver,  baryte, coal, gypsum, salt, shales, silica, sand, kaolin, Marble, Tantalite, Mica, and Feldspar. The regions combined population and net worth in 2016 stood at 20.06 million and 22.507 million USD, respectively.

The Benue Valley as an Important Geo-Political Transition Zone, serves as a link between the Northern and Southern segments of Nigeria. Six bridges cross the river ( 4 in Nigeria and 1 in Cameroun). A new one is being constructed at   Ibi. The valley is also home to some major economic hubs; Sugar Cane Production (Numan, Lau and Tunga 150,000 hectares operated by Dangote Sugar), Rice, Fish, Yam, Cassava, Vegetables, Maize, Cement and River sand Mining. As an Important Geo-Political transition zone, the Benue valley hosts the largest indigenous population of settled Fulani. It is also home to Fulani political enclaves such as the emirates of Nasarawa, Lafia, Muri, and Fombina. It exists as the socio-religious barrier between what can be loosely described as the Islamic North and non-Islamic Central Region. The valley is home to the major ethnic groups that historically halted the advance of the Jihadists from Sokoto in the early 19th century, such as the Jukun, the Gomai, the Bachama, the Tiv and the Idoma. By implication, the zone is home to the most significant number of non-Islamized people in Northern Nigeria.

Potential for Economic Development 

As Toyin Falola points out in a short but brilliant commentary on this conference, the intention is not only to historicise water bodies but also to point to how they can serve contemporary populations in the quest for economic and social development. By leveraging pointers from history, it is easy to show and demonstrate that water bodies like the Benue, when properly harnessed and managed, can catalyse the economic expansion of the basin. As noted above, the basin is an important agricultural zone,  and a major producer of crops like rice, maize, cassava, sugar and cotton. The river is rich in fish species, providing a livelihood for many communities. Developing irrigation systems and improving agricultural practices could significantly boost production. Similarly, modernising fishing techniques and developing fish processing facilities could enhance the sector. Compared to other river systems, commercial river-based fish farming is yet to be practised on the Benue. The river’s natural beauty, historical sites, and cultural heritage offer huge potential for eco-tourism and cultural tourism. River-based sporting activities can also be developed to provide recreation opportunities. The river’s flow and topography create opportunities for the construction of more hydropower dams. In addition to the Ladgo dam in Cameroon and the Kashimbilla dam on the Katsina-ala River, plans have been mooted to build another dam on the river to improve power supply, irrigation and waterway transportation.

Conclusion

Let me conclude this keynote by focusing on the specifics of Benue State University and the state itself. When Professor Joe Tor Iorapu was appointed Vice-Chancellor, I wrote him an aide memoire in which I mentioned the need to take a more than passing interest in the river behind our campus. I wrote;

The river is one of the most significant assets that we keep ignoring. We can use it to teach, research, for recreation and most importantly, make money. There is absolutely no reason why we should NOT have a “Centre for River Benue Studies”. You can kick start this with a small committee (VC’sVC’s Committee without fanfare) to put the framework together and announce the formation by the first quarter of 2021. I volunteer to work with the Committee. We can partner with firms to invest in an industrial dredger to begin to mine sand and build the largest sand pyramid in Nigeria. We can build the largest river-based fish and freshwater prawns farm in Northern Nigeria. We can build an Olympic-sized swimming pool and water park using the river as a feedstock. An industrial dredger costs about 100 million naira. Better still, it can be fabricated locally. If BSU invests in one, it will recover its money in no time. 

When I did not hear from him, I wrote a similar memo to  Professor Isaac Itodo when he was appointed Vice-Chancellor of JOSTUM. I also made a presentation to the Transition Committee of the current administration and urged them to consider the appointment of a Special Advisor on River Benue Matters. I had often wondered why the river from which the state derives its name is not usually the source of interest by succeeding governments. I am a happy person today as this conference will set the agenda for us all to take this natural endowment more seriously.

I look forward to the eight Universities in the Benue Basin to forge strategic relationships for intensive study of the river and its rich cultural, religious, and economic landscape. The newly emerging digital technologies in the water sector, often called digital water solutions, intelligent water services or digital water technologies, such as sensors, smart pumps, and meters, as well as software solutions, artificial intelligence, or machine learning applications, are emerging areas of research that our universities need to leverage .

Water has played and will continue to play a pivotal role in shaping our societies, influencing religious beliefs, driving economic activities, and influencing political structures and cultural practices. In recognising the significance of water bodies and their crucial role in fostering sustainable development, our communities and nations will increasingly be working together to find solutions to the challenges posed by water scarcity, pollution, and climate change.

Ochefu PhD, FHSN, FNAL, Professor of Economic History and Development Studies  delivered this keynote Lecture at the 2024 Toyin Falola Conference, Benue State University, July 2024.

Continue Reading

Top Stories